Paramount+ has just dropped what many are calling Taylor Sheridan’s best TV episode ever, and it’s not from Yellowstone or Landman. The honor goes to Mayor of Kingstown, a show that has quietly built a loyal fanbase since its debut.
Season 4, Episode 9, titled “Teeth and Tissue, ” has set a new record with a 9.5 rating on IMDb, surpassing even the acclaimed finale of 1923. This achievement is especially notable given that the episode serves as the penultimate chapter of an already exceptional season, which itself has a perfect 100% score on Rotten Tomatoes.
Sheridan’s influence on streaming TV is undeniable. He currently has four of the top five series trending worldwide on Paramount+, and his latest release has only solidified his reputation as a master of gritty, morally complex drama.
The fact that this record-breaking episode comes from Mayor of Kingstown, a series often overshadowed by Yellowstone, shows that Sheridan’s creative range extends far beyond Westerns and oil fields.
Mayor of Kingstown’s rise to the top spot among Sheridan’s works is a testament to the show’s evolving storytelling and character depth. Season 4 has been praised for its relentless pacing, nuanced exploration of corruption, and the emotional toll it takes on its characters.
Episode 9, in particular, has been hailed as a turning point, with critics and fans alike agreeing that it sets a new benchmark for television crime drama.
What Makes “Teeth and Tissue” So Special
The acclaim for Episode 9 is not just about numbers. Fans and critics agree that the episode delivers a powerful blend of storytelling, character development, and suspense. The narrative centers on Mike McLusky, played by Jeremy Renner, as he faces some of his toughest challenges yet.
The stakes are higher than ever, and the episode is packed with unexpected twists that keep viewers on the edge of their seats.
The episode is praised for its intricate plotting and emotional depth. Mike’s journey in this chapter is a study in moral compromise and personal collapse.
The show explores how the pressures of Kingstown, its corruption, violence, and relentless cycles of revenge can push even the most principled individuals to their limits. The cinematography and musical score add to the tension, creating a mood that is both haunting and immersive.
Mayor Of Kingstown Season 4 (Credit: Amazon Prime Video)
Several standout moments in the episode have sparked intense discussion among fans. The prison massacre, Mike’s manipulation of Frank Moses, and the shocking diner ambush are all cited as highlights that showcase Sheridan’s skill at building suspense and delivering emotional payoffs.
The prison scene is particularly memorable, as it sets the stage for a dramatic confrontation that leaves lasting consequences for the entire city. Mike’s decision to use Frank as a pawn in his larger scheme reveals the depth of his desperation and the lengths he’s willing to go to protect his family.
The episode’s final scenes set up a dramatic finale, leaving audiences eager for the next installment. The tension between Mike and his brother Mitch, the shifting alliances among the city’s power players, and the looming threat of federal intervention all contribute to a sense of urgency that permeates the episode.
The way Sheridan weaves these threads together is a masterclass in serialized storytelling, and it’s clear that every detail has been carefully crafted to maximize impact.
The Impact on Streaming and Sheridan’s Legacy
The success of Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Episode 9 has broader implications for the streaming industry. It demonstrates that audiences are hungry for complex, character-driven crime dramas, not just flashy action or broad humor.
Sheridan’s ability to craft stories that resonate with viewers, regardless of genre, is a testament to his talent and vision.
Despite the episode’s critical acclaim, Paramount+ has not yet confirmed a fifth season of Mayor of Kingstown. This uncertainty has only heightened anticipation among fans, who are hoping that the show’s record-breaking performance will secure its future.
Sheridan’s other projects, including Yellowstone and Tulsa King, continue to dominate streaming charts, but Mayor of Kingstown’s latest episode proves that there is still room for surprises in his TV universe.
Sheridan’s legacy as a storyteller is growing stronger with each new release. His work on Mayor of Kingstown, particularly in Season 4, Episode 9, sets a new standard for TV crime drama.
The episode’s record-breaking rating and widespread praise are well-deserved, and they ensure that Mayor of Kingstown will be remembered as one of Sheridan’s finest achievements.
Wake Up Dead Man sets its central puzzle around Monsignor Wicks collapsing during his Good Friday sermon, apparently stabbed in the back while alone in a prayer closet.
The door is locked, everyone else is in the sanctuary, and the impossible staging immediately gives the mystery a supernatural edge that the film then systematically strips away.
The investigation begins when local priest Jud calls in Benoit Blanc, who quickly realizes the “miracle” is a performance built on sleight of hand and timing.
According to breakdowns from Netflix’s Tudum and Time, the key detail is a pair of devil‑head ornaments; one is turned into a hidden blade, the other is filled with blood and sewn into Wicks’ vestments, ready to burst.
Blanc also learns Wicks had a secret flask, and that a remote interference pinged the church electronics at the exact moment of the collapse, pointing to technology rather than divine intervention.
By retracing each step, Blanc pieces together that Dr. Nat is the real architect of the murder. Nat spikes Wicks’ flask with a tranquilizer so the priest collapses harmlessly, then triggers the blood pack with a radio device, fooling Jud into thinking a stabbing already happened before anyone touched the body.
Later, when Nat “examines” Wicks in front of the congregation, he quietly swaps ornaments and uses the blade‑equipped devil head to deliver the actual fatal wound, counting on the earlier theatrics to confuse both witnesses and the timeline.
The locked‑room angle, which seems supernatural on first watch, turns out to be a carefully layered stage trick anchored in Nat’s medical expertise and comfort with practical props.
What makes the reveal satisfying is how it recontextualizes Jud’s guilt and the community’s faith.
Jud believed he had failed his mentor and possibly triggered the tragedy by confronting Wicks, but the evidence he hides, like the drugged flask, ultimately becomes the flaw that exposes Nat’s plan when Blanc notices it was never removed from the scene.
Critics at outlets such as the New York Times have highlighted how the film uses this reveal to challenge blind trust in religious figures and institutions, showing how easily spectacle can be weaponized by someone chasing power or money.
Greed, Eve’s Apple, And Martha’s Deadly Course Correction
If the first half centers on a fake miracle, the back half is about a fake resurrection that spins out of control. Here, the story shifts focus to Eve’s Apple diamond, an eighty‑million‑dollar jewel that becomes a magnet for every worst impulse in the town, from spiritual branding to outright fraud.
Martha, a powerful figure in the church, constructs an elaborate scheme involving Samson and Wicks’ mausoleum so she can transfer the diamond and stage a resurrection that will cement the congregation’s devotion.
As detailed by Netflix’s Tudum explainer and outlets like People, Martha plans for Samson to lie in Wicks’ coffin, then emerge from the mausoleum on camera, while Nat, disguised as Samson, plays his part.
The “miracle” footage is meant to go viral and secure both financial donations and renewed religious fervor, with Eve’s Apple quietly passed along in the process. Construction materials for opening the tomb are ordered in advance, and the camera placement around the graveyard shows just how premeditated the stunt is.
Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery (Credit: Netflix)
The entire plan shatters when two things happen: Jud unexpectedly arrives at the mausoleum, and Nat gives in to greed. Nat knocks Jud out, kills Samson, and takes the diamond for himself, leaving Jud to wake up believing he might have caused Samson’s death.
This twist turns Nat from a calculating co‑conspirator into a wildcard driven by money, and it reveals Martha’s blind spot; she assumed she could control everyone involved, but she underestimated how the promise of eighty million dollars would warp Nat’s priorities.
Later, Blanc and Jud uncover Nat’s body dissolved in a tub of toxic green sludge in his basement, alongside Wicks’ corpse, effectively stacked as evidence of the failed resurrection scheme and its fallout.
Netflix’s official breakdown and sites like Esquire note how that discovery forces Blanc to widen the frame: Nat may have executed the initial murder and double‑cross, but someone else had to bring both men to that tub and clean up the mess.
The trail leads back to Martha, whose quiet fury at Nat’s betrayal pushes her from manipulator of faith to active killer.
When Martha finally confesses, she explains that she killed Nat in revenge and tried to steer the scandal away from the church, only to realize she had crossed every line she once claimed to defend.
In a final act that mirrors the earlier poison plot, she has already dosed herself before returning to the church, and dies after begging for forgiveness, urged by Jud to acknowledge even her crimes against desperate congregants like Grace.
Time’s coverage emphasizes how her death functions as a tragic mirror to Wicks’ fake miracle; instead of rising from the tomb, Martha falls from grace in front of the very institution she tried to protect.
What The Ending Means For Benoit Blanc And The Knives Out Series
By the time the credits roll, Wake Up Dead Man has solved its whodunnit while leaving a lot of moral gray on the table.
Blanc exposes Nat as Wicks’ killer and recognizes Martha as the force behind the latter deaths. Yet, the film’s final choices show him wrestling with what justice looks like in a setting shaped by trauma, poverty, and spiritual manipulation.
He and Jud prevent Eve’s Apple diamond from falling into the hands of wealthy schemer Cy, instead hiding it inside a new crucifix Jud builds for the church, keeping its value symbolic rather than financial.
That decision has become a focal point in post‑release explainers and video essays, including heavy‑analysis channels on YouTube and articles from Men’s Health that frame the diamond as a test of character for Blanc.
In earlier Knives Out entries, Blanc typically helps redistribute power or wealth away from privileged families; here, he chooses secrecy, allowing Jud and the community to hold something precious without turning it into another spectacle.
It suggests a character who has grown more cautious about how “truth” can be weaponized once it hits social media, tabloids, and institutional spin.
For the series, the ending confirms that Rian Johnson is increasingly interested in how mystery stories can interrogate belief systems and public narratives, rather than just catching clever killers.
Critics at Variety and Netflix’s own preview materials have already framed Wake Up Dead Man as Blanc’s darkest case yet, shifting from rich families and tech bros to faith communities, cults of personality, and the commodification of miracles.
The resolution leaves Benoit Blanc alive, shaken, and still quietly furious at the ways wealth and charisma distort religion, which positions future sequels to tackle similarly charged institutions.
For viewers, that last shot of the cross hiding Eve’s Apple underlines what the entire film has been circling: sometimes the only way to protect a community is to keep temptation out of sight, even if that means bending the clean, courtroom version of justice.
Wake Up Dead Man closes not on a triumphant confession, but on a fragile act of faith between Blanc and Jud, trusting that this small church can find a better path without another spectacle built on blood, diamonds, and false resurrection.
