Netflix has teamed up with creators Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan to continue their Monster anthology series about true crime. This time, they focus on one of the most infamous crimes of the 20th century.
The nine-episode series, Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story, tells the chilling details of the brutal murders of Beverly Hills residents Jose (Javier Bardem) and Kitty Menendez (Chloë Sevigny) by their two sons, Lyle (Nicholas Alexander Chavez) and Erik (Cooper Koch), in 1989.
The show shows the murders, the premeditated plans behind them, and the trial of the brothers, who were ultimately found guilty and sentenced to life in prison without parole. It raises the question of what happened to the brothers after this true story was adapted by Murphy and Brennan.
The Menendez Brothers’ Guilty Verdicts
The series shows how the first trial ended in a mistrial. The final episode, titled “Hang Men,” focuses on the second trial from 1995 to 1996, which led to the brothers’ guilty verdicts. Leslie Abramson (Ari Graynor) takes on the case for Lyle and Erik without charging them since they have run out of money.
The close relationship between the brothers begins to weaken after spending over five years in jail awaiting a verdict. They start to blame each other for their situation, and it seems they will both be charged with first-degree murder.
Erik takes the stand again and faces tough questions from the prosecution about the planning that went into killing their parents. He claims that they acted out of self-defense because of the sexual and emotional abuse from their father, Jose, while their mother, Kitty, ignored it.
Erik continues to insist that he was defending himself. The courtroom is tense as witnesses and lawyers engage in heated exchanges. Evidence against the brothers keeps growing, and Abramson, who had previously been strong in defending them, appears overwhelmed by the amount of evidence against her clients.
Still from Monsters The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story (Credit: Netflix)
A memorable moment happens when Abramson and Erik play “Hangman” together during the trial, but they are asked to stop by the judge. Murphy shows the defeated expressions of the brothers and Abramson at their table, effectively creating a sense of doom.
Was the Murder Premeditated?
Dominick Dunne (Nathan Lane), a well-known writer for Vanity Fair, tells the story while speaking with his friends. Lyle and Erik are found guilty and face sentencing. For the first time, Murphy captures the jury as they discuss whether to sentence the brothers to death or life without parole.
A standout moment occurs when an older female juror strongly argues that the Menendez brothers should receive the death penalty.
However, a more sympathetic juror convinces the others not to sentence them to death. She points to family members who speak on behalf of Erik and Lyle. The brothers are sentenced to life in prison without the chance of parole. Abramson continues to believe that they are innocent victims and defends them passionately.
The song “Don’t Go” by Milli Vanilli plays in the background during their transfer and separation, a fitting choice since the duo was exposed as frauds for lip-synching.
The last scene of Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story shows a touching moment between Jose and Kitty during a family shark-fishing trip.
They laugh and express their love for each other. Meanwhile, Lyle and Erik, at the front of the boat, agree to kill their parents, revealing that they planned the murders during this trip. This creates a powerful sense of irony, showing how they made decisions that would change their lives forever.
New Evidence Surfaces in the Menendez Trial
The last time the Menendez brothers saw each other was in 1996, when they were kept in separate prisons and could not communicate. After their convictions, Erik and Lyle were sent to different facilities. On April 4, 2018, after many of Lyle’s appeals, they were finally reunited when Erik was moved to Lyle’s unit.
Journalist Robert Rand shared with ABC News that when Lyle saw Erik, they both “burst into tears immediately.” They embraced for several minutes without speaking, and then the prison officials allowed them to spend an hour together in a room.
In January 2017, Lyle expressed acceptance of his situation, stating, “I am the kid that killed his parents, and no river of tears has changed that and no amount of regret has changed it.”
He adds, “You are often defined by a few moments of your life, but that’s not who you are in your life, you know. Your life is your totality…You can’t change it. You just, you’re stuck with the decisions you made.”
Still from Monsters The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story (Credit: Netflix)
However, new evidence has emerged that could support the brothers’ claims of abuse from their parents. A letter from Erik to his cousin Any Cano from 1988 has been presented by their attorney, Cliff Gardner. In this letter, Erik hints at his father’s abusive behavior.
Cano testified during the brothers’ trial, but the prosecution dismissed his testimony as a lie. Additionally, Roy Rosselló, a former member of the Puerto Rican band Menudo, has claimed that Jose Menendez sexually abused him as a teenager in 1983 or 1984.
Gardner presented this new evidence in May 2023, and according to CBS News, the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office is investigating these claims. Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story is currently available to stream on Netflix in the U.S.
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (SVU) has been a staple of television for years, attracting audiences with its intense storylines and emotional depth.
Set in New York City, the series follows the Special Victims Unit of the New York Police Department as they investigate crimes that include sexual assault, domestic violence, and human trafficking.
At the forefront of the unit is Captain Olivia Benson, portrayed by Mariska Hargitay. Known for her unwavering commitment to victims, Benson embodies the show’s mission to advocate for those who have suffered trauma.
Captain Benson’s Leadership
Captain Benson’s character is a powerful symbol of resilience and hope. She has dedicated her career to ensuring that survivors of crime receive the support they need. Her leadership style is characterized by empathy, as she understands the complexities of trauma.
Throughout the series, viewers have witnessed her growth, both personally and professionally, as she shows the challenges of running the unit and dealing with her own past.
This season, Benson faces new challenges as she adapts to changes within her team. The introduction of new characters brings fresh dynamics to the show, affecting not only the investigations but also the interpersonal relationships among the squad members.
As the season unfolds, viewers see how Benson’s leadership is tested in various ways, highlighting her strength and determination.
Season 25 Overview
Season 25 introduces two new characters: IAB Captain Renée Curry, played by Aimé Donna Kelly, and FBI Special Agent Shannah Sykes, portrayed by Jordana Spiro.
Their arrival provides new energy to the series while presenting unique challenges for the existing team. As the squad adjusts to these changes, tensions and alliances shift, creating a dynamic viewing experience.
Still from Law and Order Special Victims Unit (Credit: NBC)
The season also goes deeper into the personal lives of key characters. ADA Dominick Carisi, played by Peter Scanavino, and Detective Amanda Rollins, portrayed by Kelli Giddish, are now showing their roles as new parents. Their journey adds emotional layers to the season as they balance family life with the demands of their jobs.
Each episode presents unique challenges and focuses on both the cases at hand and the personal struggles of the characters. Fans can anticipate gripping investigations intertwined with moments of vulnerability and personal growth.
Episode Highlights
“Carousel” – Episode 6
In the sixth episode, titled “Carousel,” the team confronts the aftermath of Detective Amanda Rollins’s departure. The episode follows Leah Tan, a young tourist from Singapore who becomes a victim of assault. Her friend finds her unconscious in their hostel, leading to a race against time to get her the help she needs.
As the SVU team investigates, they face numerous obstacles. Leah’s reluctance to fully cooperate stems from her fear and desire to return home. However, with the support of the team, she begins to understand the importance of justice. This episode emphasizes the challenges victims face in seeking help while also highlighting the dedicated work of the SVU team.
The emotional weight of Leah’s experience resonates throughout the episode. Viewers witness the team’s unwavering support as they work tirelessly to ensure that Leah’s voice is heard. “Carousel” serves as a reminder of the importance of advocacy and the impact that empathy can have on victims’ healing journeys.
“Marauder” – Episode 12
In “Marauder,” the story focuses on Agent Sykes as she confronts her sister Crystal’s mysterious disappearance. The anniversary of the event brings back painful memories, forcing Sykes to grapple with her emotions. The SVU team is pulled into the case as they investigate a string of abductions linked to a dangerous individual.
The episode reveals the personal stakes involved for Sykes, showcasing her determination to find her sister. The tension escalates as the investigation unfolds, leading to a dramatic confrontation with the suspects. This episode not only highlights the dangers that victims face but also illustrates the importance of teamwork and trust among colleagues.
“Marauder” effectively balances action with emotional depth. Sykes’s journey toward closure showcases the resilience of survivors and the power of solidarity. As the team works together to solve the case, they also support each other in showing their personal struggles.
“Children of Wolves” – Episode 9
“Children of Wolves” tells the story of Rosie Meadows and Sydney Lynch, two friends who face a terrifying situation in a park.
Their encounter with a group of harassers leads to violence, resulting in Sydney’s disappearance and Rosie’s injuries. The SVU team must show the complexities of the case while supporting the friends’ families.
Still from Law and Order Special Victims Unit (Credit: NBC)
As the investigation unfolds, the show highlights the broader societal issues of violence against women and the importance of community support.
The episode’s emotional impact resonates with viewers, prompting discussions about the realities many face. The bond between Rosie and Sydney underscores the significance of friendship and support during difficult times.
This episode also ties into previous plotlines, offering a sense of continuity within the series. The SVU team’s dedication to their work shines through as they strive to ensure justice for both friends. “Children of Wolves” captures the essence of the series by addressing important themes while delivering an engaging narrative.
“Third Man Syndrome” – Episode 8
The eighth episode, “Third Man Syndrome,” follows two Colombian immigrants, Javi Lopez and Teo Garcia, who experience a violent encounter while celebrating Javi’s new job. The episode goes into issues of homophobia and violence, bringing attention to the challenges faced by marginalized communities.
As the SVU team investigates the attack, they face hurdles in gathering evidence and understanding the complexities of hate crimes.
The narrative highlights the emotional struggles of the characters, particularly Teo, who must confront his fears and advocate for justice. The involvement of a former victim who bravely steps forward to testify adds another layer of complexity to the storyline.
“Third Man Syndrome” emphasizes the impact of hate crimes on individuals and communities. The episode reinforces the importance of solidarity and understanding in the face of violence. By showcasing the experiences of diverse characters, SVU continues to shed light on critical social issues.
“Tunnel Blind” – Episode 1
The season premiere, “Tunnel Blind,” sets the stage for a thrilling season. Captain Benson is deeply affected by the kidnapping of Maddie Flynn, a case that will unfold throughout the season. The episode begins with Benson’s emotional drive home from ADA Carisi and Rollins’s child’s baptism, highlighting her dedication to her work even during personal milestones.
The urgency of the case escalates as Maddie’s parents express their desperation for answers. The episode expertly intertwines moments of joy with the somber realities of the investigation. Viewers are drawn into the emotional stakes as the team works tirelessly to locate Maddie.
Still from Law and Order Special Victims Unit (Credit: NBC)
This episode serves as a powerful reminder of the complexities of balancing personal and professional lives. The dedication of the SVU team shines through as they prioritize the safety of victims, reinforcing the show’s core values.
“The Punch List” – Episode 3
In “The Punch List,” Dr. Ray Goldberg, a plastic surgeon, finds himself in a troubling situation after a night out. Encouraged by friends to indulge in drugs, he becomes a victim of assault. The episode highlights the challenges men face when seeking justice for sexual assault, as societal norms often stigmatize their experiences.
The SVU team must show the emotional fallout of Dr. Goldberg’s case while supporting him and the escort involved. The complexities of consent are examined as the investigation reveals the impact of peer pressure and societal expectations on both men and women.
“The Punch List” challenges traditional narratives about masculinity and victimhood. By addressing these themes, the episode encourages dialogue about the importance of supporting all survivors, regardless of gender. The storytelling remains sensitive and poignant, ensuring that viewers are left reflecting on the issues presented.
“Probability of Doom” – Episode 7
“Probability of Doom” tackles dark themes as Captain Benson revisits a case involving a young girl from her past. The episode begins with a chilling encounter that sets the tone for the rest of the narrative. Lisa Miller, who enters the precinct with allegations against a former abuser, becomes a focal point of the investigation.
As the SVU team goes deeper, they uncover a serial killer’s activities linked to the abuser. The story unfolds with unexpected twists, emphasizing the emotional toll on the victims and their families. The showing of trauma and retribution adds depth to the episode, highlighting the consequences of abuse.
This installment effectively captures the complexities of the justice system and the impact of childhood trauma. Viewers are left with a sense of urgency as the team works tirelessly to bring justice to the victims, reinforcing the show’s commitment to advocacy and support.
“Prima Nocta” – Episode 11
In “Prima Nocta,” the SVU team faces a high-stakes situation when a bride reports being assaulted on the eve of her wedding. The episode tackles the emotional aftermath of the assault, highlighting the bride’s struggle to reclaim her sense of safety and agency.
As the team investigates, they uncover a pattern of similar attacks, leading them to believe they are dealing with a serial rapist. The urgency of the situation prompts the squad to devise a plan that involves an undercover operation to catch the suspect.
Still from Law and Order Special Victims Unit (Credit: NBC)
“Prima Nocta” showcases the dedication of the SVU team to ensure justice is served. It also emphasizes the importance of community support for survivors as they show their healing journeys. The episode serves as a poignant reminder of the emotional complexities involved in seeking justice.
“Combat Fatigue” – Episode 10
In “Combat Fatigue,” the ongoing case of Maddie Flynn reaches a crucial turning point. As the trial of George Bouchard approaches, Maddie bravely takes the stand to confront her abductor. However, the proceedings take an unexpected turn when one juror refuses to convict, resulting in a mistrial.
Maddie’s struggles intensify as she grapples with her past trauma and battles addiction. Her mother, Eileen, portrayed by Leslie Fray, becomes increasingly desperate for justice. The episode shows the emotional turmoil faced by survivors and their families as they show the complexities of the legal system.
Captain Benson plays a pivotal role in supporting Maddie and her mother, reinforcing the importance of having a strong support system. “Combat Fatigue” highlights the resilience of survivors while addressing the real-world challenges they face in seeking justice.
“Duty to Report” – Episode 4
In “Duty to Report,” the narrative takes a personal turn for Captain Benson. When her therapist reveals a rape case involving a client, tensions rise as the victim is identified as Shea McGrath, the daughter of Benson’s Chief, Tommy McGrath. The episode shows the complexities of familial relationships and the emotional turmoil that arises when those connections are tested.
As the investigation unfolds, the SVU team faces challenges in securing justice for Shea. The episode goes into the intricacies of the justice system and the various obstacles that victims encounter. It underscores the importance of accountability and transparency within law enforcement.
Still from Law and Order Special Victims Unit (Credit: NBC)
Benson’s emotional involvement in the case adds depth to the storyline, showcasing her commitment to ensuring that justice is served. The episode effectively addresses themes of trauma, family dynamics, and the need for accountability in sensitive situations.
Final Thoughts
Season 25 of Law & Order: Special Victims Unit showcases a compelling blend of new characters, gripping storylines, and thought-provoking themes. Each episode addresses significant social issues while highlighting the personal journeys of the characters. The ongoing showing of justice, healing, and empowerment remains at the forefront of the series.
As Captain Benson leads her team through complex cases, audiences can expect both thrilling investigations and moments of deep emotional connection.
The show continues to serve as a powerful platform for discussing important topics and providing a voice for survivors. With each episode, SVU reaffirms its commitment to advocating for justice and shedding light on the challenges faced by victims.
Still from Law and Order Special Victims Unit (Credit: NBC)
As the season progresses, viewers can look forward to more attractive storylines that show the resilience of the human spirit. The blend of personal growth and professional challenges ensures that SVU remains a vital part of television, keeping fans engaged and inspired.
Season 25 stands as a testament to the series’ enduring relevance and its ability to spark meaningful conversations about justice and healing. The rich variety of characters and storylines continues to resonate with audiences, making SVU an essential viewing experience.
